I'm Julie, and I live with my husband and three young daughters in New South Wales suburbia, Australia. This is the online journal I kept until recently, of how we are trying to live more simply & sustainably in suburbia.

This blog is on indefinite hiatus but please feel free to look around my archives for some inspiration in your own journey to living more lightly and sustainably.


Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Book Review: Real Food by Nina Planck

My grandmother's cholesterol level was a source of much eye-rolling in my family for many years: she cooked all her meat in a frying pan full of lard, she ate heaps of eggs (why wouldn't she, she had free-range hens) and so on and so forth, yet she had a very low blood cholesterol level!

On the other hand, my father did all the "right" things according to the thinking of the day: no eggs, he swapped butter for margarine, the lard container in the back of the fridge disappeared (what ever happened to that Mum?) etc etc, and yet his cholesterol level was consistently higher than was deemed "healthy". I suspect that if he didn't exercise regularly and maintain a healthy weight, his doctor would have put him on cholesterol-reducing medication like millions of others around the world. Needless to say, my grandmother's low cholesterol was a source of much disgust, LOL.

Then finally, upon recently reading Nina Planck's book Real Food, the reasons for this so-called paradox were revealed: despite what the medical profession would currently have us believe, "old" foods and fats are actually good for us & the "new" foods and oils are, in fact, mostly bad!

Nina goes into much detail to explain why this is so, particularly how the many heavily-vested interests of a few U.S. food industries came to influence research results and how pharmaceutical industries rely upon us continuing to eat poorly. Cynicism about multinational companies aside, I must say how refreshing it was to read about how the traditional foods we know and (secretly) love are actually better for us than the low-fat, low-cholesterol, highly processed foods we are supposed to be eating.

I certainly can't come at low fat milk any more after reading this book, and had fortunately ditched the margarine for real butter (and not a "dairy blend") some time ago. We also don't eat much meat any more for ethical and environmental reasons, but this book most definitely made a convincing case for the health benefits of grass-fed meat over industrial meat. Nina also discusses the benefits of traditional fats such as lard and schmaltz over the modern hydrogenated oils masquerading as healthy alternatives - which is exactly why my grandmother's lard had it all over my dad's margarine in the health stakes!

She also briefly mentions the so-called French Paradox - why the French can eat such apparently rich foods and yet maintain a much healthier lifestyle than Americans. Even discounting the U.S. consumption of fast food in the equation and looking at Americans eating supposedly low-fat products, the rate of heart disease in the U.S. had actually risen since the introduction of these industrially-altered and -engineered foods. The French, on the other hand, have known for generations what real food (and fresh food!) is and enjoy it in appropriately-sized portions. Most definitely a case for Quality over Quantity.

Very much a worthy read even if you are already dedicated to whole foods - if for no other reason than it's nice to know why you were right all along :-)

12 comments:

Robert said...

One big difference between US way of living and French is not just the food, but also exercise and preventive medicine. Americans drive everywhere even if they live close by. Doctors in the U.S. make more money on you if you stay obese. There is no incentive to help you to be healthy.

Robert

Pip at Rest is not idleness said...

I really hate margarine, I prefer butter, it tastes so much better, (there is nothing better than butter on fresh, warm bread) and if I can't have butter I would rather go without, so far my cholesterol has remained below 5.5 will have to see if that book is in my library and have a read.
Pip

Veggie Gnome said...

Thanks for this book review, Julie! I am still reading "Nourishing Traditions" by Sally Fallon. The message is the same. Going back to REAL food.

Check how margarine is made - you won't want to eat it ever again. (I never did, give me butter any time. Or olive oil.)

Must check whether our library carries the book.

Gavin said...

Thanks for the book review Julie. Sounds like it needs to go on my to read list. I have also found over the last few years that by switching back to the old types of food, the ones recognised by our grandparents, have bought back so many great childhood memories and I feel better for it as well. We rarely eat processed foods now, and even switched from margarine to real butter about 3 months ago. I love it!

Gav

Anonymous said...

Hey Julie

I am also reading this book and finding it very interesting. I haven't eaten margarine for years after watching a documentary on how it is made-yuck. I like you find it interesting as she talks about what highly processed foods are doing to us. Another book I am also reading (bad habit of mine having several books on the go at once) is The Fat Fallacy by Dr Will Clower it talks about the french diet etc, but the message is the same stop the highly processed foods and enjoy natural foods with fat. He believes that we need the fat to digest our foods and also to help keep us full for longer. He talks about contolling our portions because we are eating natural healthy foods.

Cheers

Aly

littleecofootprints said...

Great review Julie. I havn’t read this book but have read Michael Pollan’s In Defense of Food which sounds like it covers similar ground. I was delighted to learn that butter was better than marg and that I had an excuse to go back to full cream milk. Maybe a little too delighted because I have gained far too many kg’s since making the switch :-(. Oops! An example of too much of a good thing I think. I need to learn from the French and go for “appropriately-sized portions” LOL.

I’m intrigued...Is that salami in the centre of the cover? Its real food?

Cheers,
Tricia

Kate@LivingTheFrugalLife said...

Yeah, schmaltz! I've recently discovered the joys of schmaltz, which is perpetually under-supplied in my home. We don't eat all that much meat either, but we make it a priority to get grass-fed and pastured meat when we do. Also, grass-fed raw milk is a REVELATION. The more I have of it, the more my body craves it. I'm positively addicted, and I love watching the color of the floating layer of fat change as the seasons change and the cows get more and more greens in their diet.

I agree it sounds as though it covers much the same territory as Pollan's In Defense of Food.

I also heard that scientists recently found that 75% of people of European extraction carry a gene that puts us at higher risk for heart disease than Asian, African or Native American populations. If so, then diet becomes even more important for us, even though we can't change our genetics.

Gard'n Judy said...

I have read "In Defense of Food" and he tells why the big companies are allowed to sell us such junk in the name of food. I am half-way through "Real Food" and she tells how to eat like our Grandmothers did. I am 60, eat pastured beef. A couple of months ago went from years of drinking skim milk to drinking whole milk. I then went from organic to non-homoginized whole milk. I was amazed that I immediately lost all of my junk-food cravings--the whole milk was the key. My cholesterol is really good and I have lost 18 lbs. I have an organic garden, and I am canning my foods so I know what goes into them--canning jams to meals in a jar (my fast food). Read all of the labels on the food that you buy. Maybe the food where you live is better, I live in the USA.

Anonymous said...

We have a saying at our house "if Great Grandma wouldn't recognize this food don't eat it"! She too had heavy cream in her coffee, real eggs for breakfast and so on. Great Grandma lived until 96! I'm on her real diet!

Joanne said...

Another butter user here! I haven't studied this issue in detail or read any of the books mentioned here, most of what I know is anecdotal.
My dad used to drive dairy tankers and has horror stories of the process involved back then in preparing and bottling milk.
I've also heard that the prevalence of canola in everything is due to politics giving big business the advantage, and likewise with soy. Too much canola is implicated in eyesight degeneration. Its very difficult to buy any packaged/processed product now that doesn't contain soy. Apparently the benefits of soy, as known in the Orient are lost in over-processing & over-consumption.
Mum cooked all our food in lard. We had small portions of meat (never enough, it seemed at the time) but none of us were overweight.
Then there's food allergies. How much is caused by the parent generation's exposure to these imitation foods, or macro amounts of foods that should be consumed in micro amounts?
Oh, and does anyone else get the creeps at those orange-juice-enriched-with-fish-oil type products?

Julie said...

Hello everyone,

Thanks for your comments :-) As Gard'n Judy says, Pollan's In Defence of Food covers why industrial food is bad for you and the environment, whereas Planck's book covers why Real Food is good for you, so I see them as complementary reading - both very good!

Cheers, Julie

Marshall said...

Hi,

We have just added your latest post "Towards Sustainability: Book Review: Real Food by Nina Planck" to our Food Directory . You can check the inclusion of the post here . We are delighted to invite you to submit all your future posts to the directory for getting a huge base of visitors to your website and gaining a valuable backlink to your site.


Warm Regards

foodnrecipes.info Team

http://www.foodnrecipes.info

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...